Stop scrolling. I can confirm Hulu has renewed All’s Fair for Season 2, just hours after that jaw‑dropping two‑episode finale. The streamer is moving fast, with production set for spring 2026. The show critics love to hate just secured its next round. And yes, that Glenn Close death‑bed scene is as wild as everyone is whispering. I watched it. I rewound it. I still cannot believe it happened.
What just happened
All’s Fair launched on November 4 and exploded out of the gate. The series pulled about 3.2 million global views in its first three days, the biggest scripted debut for a Hulu Original in three years. The Season 1 finale landed on December 9. Minutes later, the renewal was locked.
Hulu has greenlit Season 2 of All’s Fair. Production is slated for spring 2026.
The move cements a surprise truth. Reviews do not always decide a show’s fate. Attention does. Conversation does. All’s Fair drew both, for better and for chaos.
- Premiere: November 4, 2025
- Finale: December 9, 2025
- First 3 days: about 3.2 million global views
- Status: Season 2 confirmed, production this spring
How a panned show won the room
Let’s be blunt. Critics torched this series. It opened at 0 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, then crawled to a tiny single digit. They called the dialogue wooden. They called the plotting nonsense. They mocked Kim Kardashian’s performance. On paper, that should be a wrap.
But viewers showed up anyway. They came for the spectacle. They stayed for the stunt casting and couture. They argued over every courtroom monologue and perfume‑ad closeup. The show became the ultimate “hate‑watch” with benefits. You wince. You laugh. You hit play again.
Kim Kardashian made a smart pivot. She met the backlash with a wink. “Have you tuned in to the most critically acclaimed show of the year!?!?!?” she joked, sharing the drag as if it were an ad. That flipped the mood. If she was in on the bit, you could be too. It turned mean reviews into a camp invite. And a lot of fans RSVP’d.
The Glenn Close of it all
Glenn Close, playing Dina, gave the season its most talked‑about moment. The death‑bed scene, the one everyone is replaying, is transgressive and shameless. It is also perfectly cut for a pop culture moment. It is the kind of image you cannot unsee, and that is the point. The show understands shock. It packages shock like a cliffhanger you can post on a group chat. Fans quote it. They recreate it. They argue about it at brunch.
That is where All’s Fair found its power. Not in awards‑bait polish. In audacity. In big swings that spark jokes, think pieces, and costume ideas. The series is TV as spectacle, styled within an inch of its life. It is divisive, yes. It is also sticky.
If Season 2 leans into precise camp, not lazy chaos, it could turn scorched reviews into cult love.
What Season 2 needs to fix, and what it should double down on
The show has two roads. One, sharpen the writing and give the cast cleaner arcs. Two, embrace glossy camp with real intention. Right now, it sometimes plays like a serious drama that trips into parody. That gap creates whiplash.
Glenn Close is a weapon. Use her with focus. Let her lead the tone. Kim Kardashian showed comfort with the meta joke. Let her be sharper and funnier on purpose. Make the courtroom scenes actually crackle. Keep the fashion, but pair it with stakes that make sense. Most of all, own the show’s identity. If it wants to be outrageous television, be the best outrageous television.
[IMAGE_2]
Why this matters for pop culture
All’s Fair just proved a new law of modern TV. If a series can command attention, it can outrun a chorus of bad reviews. It can build weekly rituals and common language. It can turn a cringe into a catchphrase. That is cultural currency.
It also signals a shift at streamers. Metrics reward engagement, not prestige. In that world, a polarizing hit can be more valuable than a modest darling. Season 2 will test whether lightning struck once, or if this is a franchise built for the era of the gasp.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is All’s Fair renewed for Season 2?
A: Yes. I can confirm Season 2 is a go, with production planned for spring 2026.
Q: How did the show perform at launch?
A: It drew about 3.2 million global views in three days, Hulu’s biggest scripted debut in three years.
Q: Why did critics pan it?
A: They blasted the dialogue, plotting, and some performances. Many saw it as clumsy when aiming for prestige.
Q: Do I need to watch Season 1 before Season 2?
A: Yes. The finale resets several relationships, and key reveals will shape the next chapter.
Q: Will the main cast return?
A: Expect core players back. Glenn Close and Kim Kardashian remain central to the show’s identity.
Conclusion
All’s Fair just broke the rules in real time. It took a season of scathing reviews and turned it into leverage. Hulu doubled down. Fans have a new guilty pleasure to dissect. Season 2 now has a clear path. Go smarter, go camp, or go home. Either way, everyone will be watching to see which door it opens next.
